Coming in the Side Door for Amazing Ancestor Finds 2

Photo Credit: Cindy Freed

A few years back I was wandering a small local cemetery. It’s the final resting place for a number of my ancestors. Looking at family headstones I noticed the lone grave of a Civil War soldier, James R. Van Meter. His marker was engraved with an eagle and the inscription “Rest Soldier Thy Warfare is Ore”. His surname was one in my family tree but I knew he wasn’t a direct ancestor. He had to be a collateral relative. When I saw he was only 21 years old and died during the Civil War I decided to learn more about him.

What happened to James? My thoughts were racing, producing various theories. Had he been shot in battle? I wondered if he had a wife? Did he leave children? My hunch was that he didn’t leave a wife and family, given his age. I’m sure he was mourned by his parents and siblings, but I’ll bet it wasn’t too many years later that his name probably wasn’t mentioned again. Not out of disrespect of course, it’s just that life goes on. Parents pass away, siblings marry and have families of their own. Brothers or uncles who died in the war are mentioned in passing to youngsters who may or may not remember.

So here I was a century and a half later, kneeling next to this young soldier’s headstone, telling him I’d learn about his life and he’d never be forgotten. Finding more about the life and Civl War service of James R. Van Meter became an obsession.

Pvt. James R Van Meter, Co. F 4th OVC, Rockport Cemetery, Allen County, OH Photo Credit: Cindy Freed

I searched all the appropriate resources for my soldier on Ancestry, the Soldiers and Sailors Database, and FamilySearch. I found his dates of enlistment and unit he served with, Co. F 4th Ohio Volunteer Cavalry (OVC). I read the regimental history. I scoured censuses, marriage records and the pension index. My hunch was right. He didn’t seem to be married but I couldn’t account for him from the 1850 US Federal Census to the 1860 US Federal Census, right up until 6 Sep 1861 when he enlisted with the 4th OVC. I was concerned. Could it be that this young man with barely 21 years spent on this earth was more or less lost to history?

At an impasse, I went back over my research and had forgotten my notation that there was another Van Meter, George S. that enlisted in this same regiment, serving with the same company. In my research I had come to find there were many Van Meter cousins that enlisted through the course of this war from the area. So I entered the side door. I started researching George in the hopes James would show up. Boy did he ever!

I used the same research plan for George S. Van Meter finding a couple important facts. George was James’ brother, he married and sadly also died during the war. With a widow came a pension application and file. I was fortunate enough to find George Van Meter’s widow’s pension on Fold3.

As I read that pension file, my heart started pounding, my breathing quickened and I couldn’t devour the words fast enough, as my brick wall started tumbling down. In that file were two letters from George (and James’) sisters. They described how the family had moved several counties to the north when the brothers were younger. They farmed there until their father unexpectedly died in 1851 leaving their mother to raise seven children alone. Mom moved back to their original county and remarried. Her second husband was a drunk, who she divorced years later. James was specifically mentioned in a couple sentences in one letter, confirming he never married and sadly died six weeks before George was shot and killed on sentry duty outside Florence, Alabama. So many of my questions about James were answered in his brother George’s pension file. I learned where James was from 1850-1860. I was able to research that particular county and find the family there. I had a lot more information about the family and its dynamics. I can’t explain the elation I felt in finally learning about the Van Meter brothers, especially James.

I am a firm believer in cluster or collateral genealogy. Cluster genealogy is a research technique employed by genealogists to learn more about an ancestor by examining records left by the ancestor’s cluster. A person’s cluster consists of the extended family, friends, neighbors, and other associates such as business partners. Researching the lives of an ancestor’s cluster leads to a more complete and more accurate picture of the ancestor’s life.1

This approach certainly proved beneficial in researching James Van Meter. I don’t know if I would have ever have uncovered his story without his brother’s pension file. I felt real success when I was able to again kneel next to James headstone and tell him I knew about his life, his Civil War service and he was not forgotten.


  1. Wikipedia contributors, “Cluster genealogy,” Wikipedia, The Free Encyclopedia,, accessed June 28, 2017. 

Cindy Freed

About Cindy Freed

Cindy Freed is a genealogist, researcher and writer. Her blog Genealogy Circle ( documents her personal family research as well as her continuing interest in the Civil War. Along with her monthly IDG column, Tracing Blue and Gray, Cindy is a regular contributor to 4th Ohio, First Call quarterly magazine for the 4th Ohio Volunteer Cavalry Descendants Association.

Leave a comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

2 thoughts on “Coming in the Side Door for Amazing Ancestor Finds

  • Sandra Gawinski

    Dear Cindy, what a great article!
    I so enjoyed reading the above narrative regarding your genealogy research and the hunt to validate more information on this young man.
    Just yesterday I was contacted by a 2nd cousin in the state of Virginia with a similar name as mine. This amazing 75 year old female connected the dots for me after a lengthy period of my inactivity regarding my great-grandfather. There was yet another common name with the name, birthdate and birth location with a different spouse and different children. She verified that this was indeed the same descendant that we shared based on a 2nd marriage. She informed me that her research took her also to other forms of information outside the usual search areas. It was an awesome day yesterday. A couple of months ago while attempting to locate a death certificate for a confederate 3xgreat grandfather a link appeared confirming that this gentleman had 2 brothers die in the same area within months of each other, so sad! (one was just 19) is free at public libraries but fold3 has been more elusive. This article has again re-motivated me to continue the hunt, My DNA tests are bringing up even more information..and now I have learned that both my maternal grand-father and grand-mother had relatives in the Revolutionary which will improve my chances for membership in the DNA, Thank you for the tips!
    Happy hunting!